Showing posts with label evolution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label evolution. Show all posts

Saturday, 26 March 2016

Meet the world's newest lifeform: Syn 3.0

Every now and then, a piece of science is done that is truly ground-breaking and world changing. One such piece is:

Hutchison III CA et al. (2016) Design and synthesis of a minimal bacterial genome. Science 351(6280): aad6253-1. DOI: 10.1126/science.aad6253

Science has a summary here but it’s worth reading the whole paper. Syn 3.0 itself is pretty impressive, but what’s even more impressive is the approach taken to make it. In addition to using current knowledge of fundamental biological machinery, the Venter group used large-scale transposon mutagenesis and selection to identify additional genes that were either essential (i.e. no growth without them) or “quasi-essential”, where removal resulted in a major growth deficit.

They also had to overcome the problem of redundancy: even in a genome as reduced as the Mycoplasma species, there can sometimes be multiple genes that do the same thing. Removing one makes little difference but removing both is lethal - something hard to identify when knocking out single genes at a time. Whatever the Intelligent Design crowd would like to believe, biology is messy.

Of course, Syn 3.0 is just the start, as the goal was making a “minimal cell”:

“A minimal cell is usually defined as a cell in which all genes are essential. This definition is incomplete, because the genetic requirements for survival, and therefore the minimal genome size, depend on the environment in which the cell is grown. The work described here has been conducted in medium that supplies virtually all the small molecules required for life. A minimal genome determined under such permissive conditions should reveal a core set of environment-independent functions that are necessary and sufficient for life. Under less permissive conditions, we expect that additional genes will be required.”

Robust life will therefore need a lot more genes. It will be interesting to see how many are required for autotrophy - life that needs only inorganic chemicals and an energy source.

Even within the “minimal cell” concept, Syn 3.0 represents a somewhat arbitrary end-point. In identifying the “quasi-essential” genes, a judgement had to be made regarding what constitutes an acceptable growth rate*. Whittling down to 473 genes is impressive, but this number could no doubt be even smaller if slower growth rates were accepted. (Modern life is in competition with lots of other highly evolved organisms. Early life would have been able to get by with much lower growth rates, so this is not a “minimal cell” in that context.)

There is also a lot of exciting potential ahead for manually reducing the number of genes by true intelligent design. Fusing interacting gene products together, for example, might eliminate the need for so many genes contributing to core processes. (Looking for apparent protein fusion/fission events in evolution is a reasonably successful method for predicting protein-protein interactions.) With time, we might be able to “wind back the clock” and remove some of the unnecessary complexity that has probably crept into the system due to the underlying evolutionary process.

I also wonder how many of the current crop of genes of unknown function - a surprising 149 genes - can be replaced over time with genes of known function. (In other words, how many of them represent convergent evolution of functions we already know about but are not recognisable.) And how many of the rest are genome-/condition-specific?

Like all of the best science, this work opens the door to more questions than it answers! Some exciting times ahead, I think.

[*The important but oft-overlooked concept that any assessment of life is context- and environment-dependent exposes another flaw with Intelligent Design as a testable hypothesis: designed to do what? To assess how well-designed something is, one needs to know its purpose and/or the acceptable design traits. To hide from the fact that Intelligent Design is Creationism, supporters often make the argument that the identity of the designer (Creator) is not important - but without knowledge of the designer, how can one predict the motivation behind the design?]

The blood of dinosaurs

Courtesy of sciencegasm. Remember this when you see any cute Easter chicks*...

[*Yes, I know it’s not a baby chicken. Some kind of gull, maybe?]

Sunday, 21 June 2015

The importance of knowing how your data are scaled

A few weeks ago, there was a post on WEIT, The correlation between rejection of evolution and rejection of environmental regulation: what does it mean? It was triggered by a tweet about by the Washington post about a graph comparing attitudes to the environment and attitudes to evolution, broken down by religious affiliation:

We’ll get to the tweet later. First, the graph. It was from a US National Center for Science Education blog post based on 2007 data from the Pew Religious Landscape Study, examining two binary choice statements:

y-axis. Stricter environmental laws and regulations cost too many jobs and hurt the economy; or Stricter environmental laws and regulations are worth the cost.

x-axis. Evolution is the best explanation for the origins of human life on earth. (Agree/disagree)

Data was normalised onto a percentile scale with each circle representing (1) by position, the normalised percentile of that group’s response, (2) by area, the size of that group. (36,000 people were surveyed in total.)

The percentile normalisation method was based on a previous analysis of different Pew questions by Toby Grant, who explains it thus:

Geek note on measurement

The range of each dimension ranges from zero to 100. These scores were calculated by calculating the percentage of each religion giving each answer. The percentages were then subtracted (e.g., percent saying “smaller government” minus percent saying “bigger government”). The scores were then standardized using the mean and standard deviation for all of the scores. Finally, I converted the standardized scores into percentiles by mapping the standardized scores onto the standard Gaussian/normal distribution. The result is a score that represents the group’s average graded on the curve, literally.

A few things annoy me about this:

  1. This is not simply a “Geek note”. Knowing what was done to data is vital for understanding what a plot means. To be fair to Grant, he does mention that he is plotting percentiles in the graph legend. (As far as I can see, Robineau does not mention it anywhere!)
  2. By first normalising to the mean and then converting everything to percentiles, there is a double loss of quantitative information. Following the first normalisation, all you can do is compare groups - there is no absolute information about responses. Following the second, you cannot even compare the degree of difference. What this plot is basically doing is pulling in the outliers to make them look more similar to mean, and spreading out those similar to the mean to make them look more different.
  3. When converting to percentiles, the additional normalisations seem pointless. Unless I've misunderstood, if the data is truly normally distributed then the percentile of the fitted data should be the same as the percentile of the raw data. If not, you shouldn’t do the normalisation in the first place. Either way, I think you are just adding error and confusion. (There is no data presented to support the fact that these opinions are normally distributed.)

It is also worth noting that, to the unwary, the circle sizes could be misleading. The bigger the circle, the more data and the more accurate the estimation of the value. The small circles might have much more random sampling bias in their positions. (Under a null model where all groups are the same, you would expect the large circles to gravitate towards the mean, while the smaller circles should be the outliers.) Most importantly, circles that overlap are not more similar than circles that do not.

It would be more useful to have estimated standard errors plotted for each group. Again, because we have lost the quantitative information, we cannot tell whether a small difference in responses (possibly within measurement error) would have a big difference in percentiles. There are 36,000 people in total but some of the groups are less than 0.5% and therefore have fewer than 200 people.

Robineau’s plot uses the same method although he:

“didn’t rescale to the 0-100 scale, since I didn’t want this to seem like a percentage when it isn’t.”

It's not a percentage but it is a percentile, so 0-100 is entirely appropriate. Leaving it as -1.0 to +1.0 is in fact very misleading, as it implies that people are positive or negative with respect to the questions. In reality, positive just means “above average” and negative is “below average”. I have an above average number of arms: two. This does not mean that I have lots of arms, it just means that some people have fewer arms than me.

These things aside, Robineau asks:

“So what does this tell us?

Thanks to the scaling, the only thing this graph tells us is that (a) there is a rank correlation between the answers to the two questions, and (b) some religious groups (particularly evangelical Christians) appear to agree with these statements less than average, while other groups (notably non-Christians) tend to agree with these statements more than average.

These observations could still be of interest. The real problem comes when people start interpreting this graph as if the normalisations and rescaling have not been done to it. Robineau first:

First, look at all those groups whose members support evolution. There are way more of them than there are of the creationist groups, and those circles are bigger. We need to get more of the pro-evolution religious out of the closet.

Second, look at all those religious groups whose members support climate change action. Catholics fall a bit below the zero line on average, but I have to suspect that the forthcoming papal encyclical on the environment will shake that up.”

This in turn was apparently interpreted by the Washington post to mean this:

The fact is, the normalisation has removed all hope of actually knowing whether there is conflict or not. The percentile scaling removes almost all of the quantitative info on the axes, so proximity on the scale means nothing with respect to proximity of answer. All the groups inside the small top right cluster could have >90% support for the scientific evidence and all of the groups outside <10% support, and you could still get that plot. (It’s hard to tell but the top-right cluster look closer to 1.0 than the bottom-left groups are to -1.0, indicating that they might deviate much more from the mean thanks to the mapping onto a normal distribution. This implies that the data was not normally distributed in the first place and is probably a heavy-tailed or bimodal distribution instead.)

Critically, it is impossible to conclude that any groups “support evolution” or “support climate change action”. As the graph is scaled by percentiles, 0.0 is essentially the point where 50% are above and 50% below. Because the vast majority of groups are religious, of course there are many religious groups above the line. There essentially have to be, unless all religious groups were identical (in which case they would group very slightly below 0.0).

To many, stand-out thing is that atheists and agnostics are all in the top-top right. This graph could easily have been branded “the conflict between science and religion in one chart”! But it cannot even really say that: every group could disagree with the two statements and thus be in conflict with the scientific evidence. You would still get the same plot after the rescaling.

My big question from all of this is: why not make the plot using the raw percentage responses? What do the normalisations actually achieve?

And my big take home message: if you are going to infer things from plots, make sure that you understand how the data were scaled.

Saturday, 20 June 2015

MapTime lives!

MapTime

It’s fair to say that MapTime has been somewhat neglected in the past couple of years, now that the core team is spread over three continents. However, having given the website a long overdue look over today (after it went down a while ago), I am pleased to report that it still works! I even added a new TimePoint to the Organic Evolution TimeLine.

Thursday, 30 April 2015

Sunday, 26 April 2015

Best journal cover ever?

Courtesy of the Molecular Biology and Evolution Facebook page comes this awesome cover art:

According to the MBE Editor:

The author and artist info: The cover image depicts representative squamate species (lizards and snakes) playing poker, with the card and chip colors representing the sex-determining system most prevalent in each clade. The tabletop shows results from a comparative genomic analysis of squamate sex-determining mechanisms by Gamble et al in this issue. This study discovered that changes between sex-determining mechanisms in one clade, geckos, account for a half to two-thirds of the total transitions known in lizards and snakes. This remarkable frequency of transition is reflected in the illustration by the heightened activity at the gecko side of the table: the three gecko species in the foreground are cheating, implying that when it comes to sex determination, geckos do not play by the rules. The image was created by University of Minnesota biologist and artist Anna Minkina and pays homage to the Cassius M. Coolidge painting, “A Friend in Need”, part of the artist’s “Dogs Playing Poker” series.

h/t: James McInereny

Thursday, 12 February 2015

A lego HMS Beagle for Darwin Day

It’s Darwin Day again, and what better way to celebrate than to support the awesome work of LuisPG by voting for his outstanding rendering of “HMS Beagle: A Voyage of Researches”:

The eight minifigures include some all-time favourites for fans of The Voyage of the Beagle, or anyone following Darwin’s tweets/blog of his travels. (He’s around Cape Horn at the moment.)

The Charles Darwin’s Beagle Diary blog features extracts from the diaries of Darwin, Fitzroy and Syms Covington, as well as artwork from Conrad Martens, so it’s good to see them all feature!

There’s more pictures and info at the “Lego ideas - HMS Beagle” page, and in the designer’s flickr album. So go, register (if you need to) and give the Beagle a vote: it’s what a 206 year old Darwin would have wanted.

Friday, 5 December 2014

Edwards Lab: On the hunt for molecular mimicry in viral pathogens

Yesterday’s excellent Australian Pathogen Bioinformatics Symposium 2014 (#APBS2014) reminded me that this post was a bit overdue: originally posted at the UNSW Science Wavelength blog on October 30, 2014. Following APBS2014, we are also looking into how we can identify which other pathogens might be using a similar strategy.

Read more at the Edwards Lab blog…

Thursday, 13 February 2014

Belated Happy Darwin Day!

It’s still (just) Darwin Day in some places but I must confess that it came upon me too fast this year. Still, it’s a good excuse to revisit some of the previous Darwin posts about Darwin and Wallace, Darwin the gentleman scientist and last year's Darwin quotes for Darwin Day.

Better still, check out some Darwin Day posts from elsewhere: How Darwin took on Intelligent Design at the Rationalist Association, or a suite of posts at Why Evolution is True, including Darwin’s pet tortoise!

Monday, 10 February 2014

Observational versus Historical Science

One of the things that Ken Ham made a big deal about during the recent Nye vs Ham debate was his distinction between “Observational Science” - things we observe now - and “Historical Science” - inferences from the past that we can never know because we can never go back. Historical Science, he argues, can never be verified/falsified, is built on assumptions, and could therefore be wrong. He then makes the giant leap (of faith) that because it could be wrong, it can safely be dismissed when it does not fit his Young Earth Creationist (YEC) worldview. (A world-view, ironically, built on the trust of an historical text that he cannot go back and see written and therefore cannot know is authentic!) He then accused science textbooks of being misleading because they fail to make this distinction between the observational and historical.

Bill Nye dismissed this distinction. However, although he gave hints, he did not really explain why it was wrong. So, who’s right? It seems fair enough to divide what can be seen from what is only inferred, doesn’t it? Is Ken Ham right?

No.

As was abundantly clear when Ken Ham tried to give examples of “observational science” that supported the YEC position versus “historical science” that did not, dividing scientific conclusions along these lines is confusing, meaningless and demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of how science works. The real division - the aspect of the argument that appears to have merit - is between data and interpretation.

In science, data is sacred. This is the “observational” aspect. A fossil either exists or it does not. A DNA sequencing machine returns a particular order of nucleotides. Light has a particular measured wavelength etc. But, data by itself does not mean anything. Its meaning is derived from the interpretations of that data, based on certain assumptions and interpretation in the context of other data and evidence.

Crucially, this interpretation - and the required for underlying assumptions - is true for all observations and all science. The methods, techniques and models etc. that we apply to contemporary data are the same as those applied to “historical” data. There is nothing inherently more or less reliable about one or the other. Contemporary “observations” are rarely direct observations - they also require assumptions and knowledge of technical error rates etc. DNA sequencing, for example, is not literally observing nucleotides: it is interpreting patterns of fluorescence, or changes in electric current. Technical errors - and human mistakes - can happen.

Now, that does not mean that all scientific conclusions are equally reliable. The confidence in a conclusion will depend on the confidence of the underlying assumptions and models; these in turn are determined by how consistently those assumptions and models fit/explain other data. This is another mistake of the Creationist crowd (including Intelligent Design Creationism): they mistake possibility for probability.

Confidence is also determined by how readily we could spot something awry with the model/assumption in question. In other words, if the assumption is wrong, how would we expect the results of a particular experiment to deviate from the expected results if the assumption is right. This is what it means to be falsifiable and this is what scientists do on a day-to-day basis: test their models and assumptions and try to break them. If the assumptions seem to hold, we keep the interpretation - or suite of possible interpretations - that result. If not, we go back to the drawing board and try to come up with new models and assumptions that work with the new data and still work with the old data. The interpretation of the data is then updated in the light of the new model. Critically, we do not build the assumptions on the conclusion. This is why science changes its best interpretation - and gets less wrong with time; YEC does not.

It is certainly true that some data is easier to come by than others and, as a general rule, we have less confidence about things the further back in time we go. But, this is nothing to do with observation versus history; it is everything to do with abundance (or paucity) and variety of data. We have more confidence about recent things because we can generally get more - and more varied - data more easily. This is not universal, though, and when the data is absent we have little confidence regardless of the age. We have far more confidence in the age of the Earth than the Higgs boson, for example. Likewise, where we have weak, untested models and assumptions - or messy data for which the correct assumptions cannot be established - we have little confidence. Where we have robust well-validated models, we have high confidence.

Radiometric dating is a case in point. As exemplified by Ken Ham, the YEC crowd love to pull out examples where radiometric dating goes wrong - usually featuring recent volcanic eruptions. When doing so, they completely neglect whether we expect those examples to give reliable dates. We don’t! They are often messy scenarios where the inherent assumptions of the dating techniques are likely to be violated. (Sometimes, they are completely inappropriate scales and/or ignore measurement error.) This does not mean that those assumptions are always questionable and the techniques are always unreliable. Whether the conditions give us confidence that the underlying assumptions are correct - clear strata, for example - dating methods are incredibly accurate and consistent. (For a good discussion of when radiometric dating is (not) reliable, see here.) If you want to go after a scientific theory, you have to attack the strongest evidence, not the weakest.

All science is both observational and historical. The science of an Old Earth and the common ancestry of all (known) life on Earth are as confident and observational as the particle physics that made possible the computer on which I type these words. Ken Ham is just plain wrong. Again.

Wednesday, 5 February 2014

Ken Ham demonstrates that Young Earth Creationism is a purely religious theory and not scientific

Like many evolutionary biologists (and scientists in general), I had deep reservations about Bill Nye’s decision to debate Ken Ham today at the Creation Museum in Kentucky. My reservations were three-fold:

  1. Debates are not about truth, they are about winning - science, the complete opposite. Science is settled by data and lengthy rational discussion in the scientific literature, not by one hour grandstanding without any real-time fact-checking.

  2. All the ticket and DVD sales go to directly undermine his life’s work. (i.e. funding The Creation Museum.)

  3. Bill Nye is not an evolutionary biologist and I was not sure that he would have the knowledge at his fingertips required to counter the bizarre unusual examples that Creationists always like to drag out in an attempt to discredit some aspect of evolutionary theory. (I know I couldn’t without the internet and time to look into them!)

I even uttered the words (or whatever the online equivalent of utterance may be): He’s “lost” before he even starts.

Like many evolutionary biologists (and scientists in general), I also did not intend to watch the debate, believing it to be a train-wreck in the making. When, however, a reminder from Why Evolution is True popped up in my inbox just after I had got myself a coffee, I changed my mind - I hadn’t even realised it would be on at a sensible time Down Under. (11am as it happens.)

Happily, I was wrong on a few counts. Bill Nye made a very good account of himself. Ken Ham did not wind me up like Creationists are prone to do and, whilst contradicting himself in places and misrepresenting specific scientific techniques on occasion, he was actually fairly easy to listen to and made a compelling case: just not the case I think that he thought he was making - but I’ll come back to that.

I’m still not sure that Bill Nye should have agreed to do it but three realisations/revelations (four if you count his performance) have certainly made me question my earlier judgement:

  1. The topic. Crucially - and in a big mistake by Ken Ham - the debate was not “Creation versus Evolution”. Ham was not able to pull out the usual Creationists smoke and mirrors, partly because he is a Young Earth Creationist (YEC) and has little room for manoeuvre. Instead, the topic was: “Is creation a viable model of origins in today’s modern scientific era?” By putting the focus on YEC and not evolution, there was less of the focusing on gaps in our knowledge (as if they somehow invalidate the positive evidence) and more focus on the evidence - or lack of it - for YEC.

  2. Apparently, the ticket sales would not be sufficient to cover the costs of running the event, so the Creation Museum might actually make a loss. I am sure that they will recover this from DVD sales to the faithful, although given how exposed the YEC position was in the debate, I’m not sure they’ll want to.

  3. Rather than simply being a debate between the two, they also had to answer questions handed in by the public. These were some of the most revealing of all.

There are a lot of points from the debate that are worthy of discussion, and I might write a few more posts in future if I have the time/energy. One point really stood out, though, so it is worthy of a mention now.

The end is Nye for Young Earth Creationism as “Science”

One of the most interesting things was how Ken Ham did not even try to pretend that his YEC was not wholly and utterly derived from his religious belief. This was not a matter for debate and it was Ham, not Nye, that exposed it. He made it clear that, in his view, Christian theology does not make sense without a literal Biblical Creation. (I happen to agree with him there but that’s definitely another post!) He also made it clear that Genesis was the starting point, had to be true and there was absolutely no way that he would ever accept any evidence or interpretation that contradicted it.

One of the questions from the public was what it would take for the speakers to change their mind. For Nye: a bunch of different observations incompatible with naturalistic evolution and/or an old Universe. For Ham: nothing.

Ham’s tactic to cover this up was a new one to me, I must confess. Rather than claim that YEC is not a religious position, he claims that “molecules to man” evolution is a religious position. (Rather odd given the number of “Theistic evolution” religious believers out there.) Apparently, not believing the Bible is a literal God-inspired manual for life that trumps all evidence - even if that opinion is itself based on external evidence - is religion.

He then made a big effort to convince people that YEC is consistent with the evidence. There were the usual quotes from YEC PhDs and a big thing about distinguishing “observable science” and “historical science”. (From what I can gather, anything that can be shoehorned into being “consistent” with YEC is “observable science”, and anything that cannot is “historical science” and therefore “impossible to know” and open to other interpretations.) He also made a big thing of scientific interpretations being based on “assumptions” and therefore quite possibly wrong, whereas he could present a different set of assumptions and suddenly the data is consistent with the Bible.

And here is the crux of the matter. With these admissions, Ken Ham is demonstrating exactly why YEC is not science - and why a scientific interpretation of evidence is not religion...

Religion starts with the conclusion and makes up assumptions to fit the data to it. Science, on the other hand, starts with a set of assumptions and then asks what conclusions are most feasible given the data and these assumptions. This is big difference between science and religion - between evolution and YEC. Does the conclusion lead the interpretation of the data or does it fall out of it?

Crucially, where YEC invents assumptions to make the data fit, the assumptions of science are themselves scientific conclusions and/or explicitly tested. For science, it is not enough to simply say that data X is consistent with explanation Y. For science to accept Y as the current working explanation, data X has to be more consistent with Y than competing explanations. Certainly, Ken Ham’s team can come up with all manner of just-so unlikely explanations as to why apparent evidence for an old earth or shared ancestry can be explained away but are they likely? More to the point, what are the chances of them all being right? YEC ignores the weight of consistent probability that opposes their position - because their position is not derived from evidence. As Ham and Nye made clear together: in the modern scientific era, this is just not a viable model of origins without extraordinary faith in deceptive powers.

Of course, YEC starting with its conclusion and therefore not being science is an old chestnut but I still find it interesting that Ham did nothing to dispel this and actually reinforced it. I’m doubtful that this debate will make any difference but it really should have put the misguided representation of YEC as science to bed, once and for all.

Saturday, 21 December 2013

Alfred Russel Wallace unveiled

I’m still not sure why Alfred Russel Wallace always has his middle name used, like the assassin of a an American president, but his statue has just been unveiled at the Natural History Museum. Wallace was not forgotten and Darwin did not cheat him out of due credit for Natural Selection. Nevertheless, his contributions to biology were numerous and important and his independent realisation of the mechanism Natural Selection should be no less applauded just because he was second. It is therefore great that he now has a statue at the Natural History museum.

You can watch a video of the unveiling below (unless it gets pulled - the source is unclear). It is great (and somewhat refreshing) to hear David Attenborough emphasise the comradery and friendship of Darwin and Wallace, rather than (as others are prone to do) spouting conspiracy theories that diminish both men.

Monday, 9 December 2013

Explosive palaeontology

When one pictures fossil hunters, one normally imagines someone carefully chipping and brushing away at some exposed rock. The picture that springs to mind is rarely someone sitting on a box of explosives. With Professor Mike Archer at UNSW, however, that’s exactly what you get.

I first found out about Mike’s extraordinary approach to fossil hunting at the UNSW family BBQ a couple of weeks ago. As described in the Australian Wildlife notes on Riversleigh, a world heritage fossil site in north-western Queensland: (my emphasis)

As water dissolves the rock, bones and teeth can be seen protruding from the rock. Releasing them from the rock is not so easy. Quarrying techniques must be used, including the occasional use of light explosives. Many of the areas are so inaccessible that the larger rocks have to be broken up with sledge hammers, bagged and labeled and lifted out by helicopter.

Once they finally reach the laboratory, the fossils are freed by dissolving away the surrounding limestone with dilute acetic acid. After treatment with preservatives, the fossils are then ready for study by scientists.

This approach has reaped rewards, including the recently reported giant toothed platypus fossil.

Another example of dramatic palaeontology doing the rounds is the amazing set of dinosaur footprints in a Bolivian quarry, which presumably were unmasked by something similarly explosive.

Opponents of evolution often point erroneously at the gappy nature of the fossil record, conveniently ignoring that not only do past organisms need to have been subject to the relatively rare conditions that result in fossilisation but then that bit of rock needs to be exposed again and then someone needs to find it before it’s destroyed! Given of all this, I think that the fossil record is actually remarkably complete! (Not to mention, of course, that even as more and more fossils get added, the fossil record is entirely consistent with evolution and extremely inconsistent with a recent global flood or Young Earth Creationism.)

Thursday, 22 August 2013

Little Changes: teaching evolution, one rhyme at a time

Today, I was catching up with some old podcasts. One was the Naked Genetics podcast from last January, which featured a book that I had never heard of but sounded rather cute. It’s called Little Changes and was written by Dr Tiffany Taylor from the University of Reading as a way to introduce evolution (by Natural Selection) to under 11s - and their teachers. I’ve not got it - I don’t have any under 11s - but the preview on Amazon looks fun and the illustrations look sweet too.

I won’t reproduce any sample text here as it is all copyrighted but you can “look inside” on Amazon if you are interested. Apart from someone who (ambitiously) got it for their three year old, the customer reviews are good too.

Wednesday, 21 August 2013

Darwin and Wallace at Burlington House

For more on Darwin and Wallace, have a read of today’s guest post on Why Evolution is True by Greg Mayer, Darwin and Wallace at Burlington House. With extensive references and direct quotes from Wallace himself, it makes an interesting read.

The accusations against Darwin are that he ‘stole’ one or more ideas from Wallace, and that the circumstances of the reading and publication of the Linnean Society papers were somehow unethical. Although ostensibly arguing on Wallace’s behalf, these authors must dismiss Wallace’s own accounts (e.g. 1870, 1889, 1905, 1908) of the contributions made by Darwin and himself, and paint Wallace as a victim. But, as his biographer Raby (2001:291) says, “Wallace was not a victim, and he did not see himself as a victim”; to do so “diminishes both Darwin and Wallace.”

Hopefully the conspiracy theorists will now stop diminishing both of these great Victorian scientists and celebrate them both.

Wednesday, 14 August 2013

Wallace was not forgotten and Darwin did not cheat him

A while ago, I watched - and really enjoyed - Bill Bailey’s Jungle Hero about Alfred Russell Wallace, the “co-discover of Natural Selection”. (I’m not sure why, like assassins of American Presidents, Wallace always has his middle name used.) It was an excellent two-part documentary in which Bailey retraces some of the steps of Wallace in his epic and life-changing - in fact, world-changing - expeditions through Borneo and Idonesia that resulted in the publication of his joint paper with Dariwn in 1858, On the Tendency of Species to form Varieties; and on the Perpetuation of Varieties and Species by Natural Means of Selection.

What annoyed me a little, however, was the degree to which the show seemed to buy into two legends about Wallace and his relationship with Darwin: (1) Wallace was forgotten whilst Darwin took all the credit, and (2) Darwin somehow cheated Wallace out his due recognition. As far as I can tell, neither is really the case.

Perhaps I have a twisted view of things as an evolutionary biologist but, even before this year’s activities in honour of the hundred years since his death, Wallace has not been forgotten. He is still lauded as a scientific hero among evolutionary biologists, with several key insights attributed to him. As well as a bunch of species, he has had geographical features named after him, including the Wallace Line and adjoining Wallacea, and is known as “the father of Biogeography”. There is a reason that Darwin is given more credit when it comes to evolution - he did come up with Natural Selection first and as it was the theory was largely ignored until On the Origin of Species was published. (It’s worth reading an interesting and informative post at Why Evolution is True by Greg Mayer, Why is Darwin more famous than Wallace?) But more credit to one does not equate to no credit to the other.

I’ve also never really understood the big deal about the chain of events that resulted in the 1858 joint publication. If, the story goes, if Wallace had only sent his idea direct to publication when he first had it rather than sending it to Darwin then it would have been just the Wallace theory of Natural Selection. (Except that Wallace did not use that term, so it probably would have been called something else.) Perhaps. But, equally, if Darwin had sent his theory for publication when he first had it, Wallace would never have thought of it because it would have already been a solved problem before he even went to Asia. It seems that Wallace is more lucky than unlucky to be heralded the "co-discoverer".

Then there is the even stronger claim that Wallace was not just unlucky, but that Darwin actively did the dirty and cheated him. Apart from the fact that this does not seem to fit with all the evidence that Darwin was an honorable and kind gentleman (included the friendship between Wallace and Darwin), I always thought that if he really wanted to do the dirty on Wallace then some “accident” could easily have befallen the letter.

Having said all that, I’ve not looked into it deeply and have often wondered whether it really was just anti-establishment conspiracy theories or whether there was more to it. I was therefore very interested to read John van Wyhe’s Guardian piece last Friday, Darwin did not cheat Wallace out of his rightful place in history. The title says it all really and you can (and should!) read the article if you are interested to know more - it’s not very long.

The reason why John van Wyhe’s viewpoint is so notable is that he is the founder and chief editor of the both the Darwin Online and Wallace Online websites and has studied the source material in depth. He has also just written a new book about Wallace, “Dispelling the Darkness:Voyage in the Malay Archipelago and the Discovery of Evolution by Wallace and Darwin” - you can read a review in another WEIT post. It looks interesting.

Friday, 7 June 2013

Putting Archaeopteryx back on its perch?

Around this time last year, the sad news came out that South Korean textbook publishers were removing examples of evolution following pressure from Creationists. [Soo Bin Park (2012) South Korea surrenders to creationist demands. Nature 486:14.] One of the examples to be dropped was Archaeopteryx, on the grounds that it might not be an ancestral bird after all. I am not sure how they will respond to last week's news that recent research puts Archaeopteryx back in the bird lineage, as opposed to being "just another feathered dinosaur". (Just‽)

The study in question, A Jurassic avialan dinosaur from China resolves the early phylogenetic history of birds [Godefroit et al., Nature (2013) doi:10.1038/nature12168], describes a 170-million-year-old fossil (below). Twenty million years or so older than Archaeopteryx, Aurornis xui is touted as the earliest definite early bird. (Artist's reconstruction, above.) Furthermore, the traits it shared by the two seem to put Archaeopteryx fully back within the ancestral avian lineage.

The authors include one of my Southampton colleagues, Gareth Dyke, and you can hear him discuss the paper on the Nature Podcast at the Nature News article, New contender for first bird. You can also read a summary in the Science news of the week - Science 340:1024-1025, Earliest Birdie? [Pictures from the linked Nature and Science news items.]

Of course, whether or not Archaeopteryx is an ancestral bird or not, that does not alter the irrefutable fact that birds did evolve from dinosaurs. The real solution to the challenge by Creationists should not have been to take Archaeopteryx out of the textbook but to put more fossils into the textbook. Teach the actual "controversy", such as it is: from which dinosaurs did birds evolve?

Tuesday, 30 April 2013

Charles Darwin, the gentleman scientist

Yesterday, we went to Down House, the home of Charles Darwin, with a friend from the US. I've been meaning to go for a while and, as an evolutionary biologist, I guess it is something of a Pilgrimage. (Somehow fitting, therefore, that my Tom Tom Sat Nav decided to direct via all the country backroads, including Pilgrim's Way.) The house is now looked after by English Heritage and features some great exhibits and insights into the great man's life.

As I am reading the blog of Darwin's Beagle diaries, I was initially most interested in the material from that time of his life, including the reconstruction of his cabin on the Beagle. Perhaps what struck me most, though, was Darwin the man, not Darwin the scientist.

Darwin was a gentleman in every sense. It is true that he was independently wealthy and never had to work for his money, being the son of a very successful doctor and financier. Although he did not eschew this inheritance (honestly, who would?!) it is clear that he did not take his fortune for granted. I have already seen glimpses of his opposition to slavery in his journal comments but it was clear from Darwin House that he was also a kind employer to those paid to serve on his staff. His butler, Joseph Parslow, for example was described on his headstone as "Faithful servant and friend of Charles Darwin" and used to play billiards with Darwin. One of Charles Darwin's sons, Frances, wrote (quote taken from TwoJays):
"“As a master of servants he was much loved and respected; he always spoke to them with politeness, using the expression "would you be so good" in asking for anything. And he was considerate in giving them trouble, one little thing I remember, how he used to reprove one for using a useless number of spoons because it gave so much more trouble in cleaning."
On the subject of Darwin's children, the other thing that really came across from the house and the quotes taken from letters etc. was how much he cared for his family. Not only was Darwin a keen lover of nature, he was a loving husband and a doting father. It is not hard to imagine Down House and its gardens as the site of happiness and fun as well as some of the most influential science of the modern age.

Critics of Darwin often try to make him out as some kind of monster, as if discrediting the man can discredit the science. Of course, this is nonsense on many levels. Newton, it seems, was a pretty nasty piece of work but his scientific genius remains. In Darwin's case, not only has the science stood the test of time but the character of the man himself deserves respect, whether you accept the scientific truth of evolution by Natural Selection or not.

Wednesday, 17 April 2013

How to read a phylogenetic tree

This week I have been preparing my last phylogenetics lectures and practical of the year. Something that is quite clear when marking student work is that many students have no idea how to read a phylogenetic tree and identify the key features about it that aid interpretation. To help combat this, here is my basic guide of "How to read a phylogenetic tree".

Topology

The first and possibly most important thing about any tree is the topology - the branching order. It's easy to get distracted by the direction or style of the tree (e.g. curved branches versus straight) but none of these things matter for the topology. The key thing here is the path taken from one node to the other and how the species (or molecules but I will just refer to species here for clarity) cluster together. The "direction" of the tree and whether the (terminal) "leaf" nodes are at the top, bottom, left or right is not important. (I'll come back to this below, for "rooting") Likewise, the vertical ordering of nodes is not inherently important - whether a particular node appears at the top, bottom or somewhere in the middle of the tree is largely a matter of preference that will depend on the purpose of the tree and the story you are using it to tell.

In fact, it is easier to look at the branches in a tree, as nodes can be rearranged in a way that can at first appear confusing. These four trees, for example, all have the same topology:
Each branch can be thought of as dividing the tree in two and splitting the species into two accordingly. If two trees share a topology, their branches will make the same splits, even if their (in this case) vertical ordering is different. Trace, for example, the path from A to D. This is easiest first in the top left tree. The branch leading directly to A splits the tree into A:BCDE. The next splits AB from CDE. (This has the root, which I will come to, below.) Now, moving back out from the root to the tip, we travel along a branch that splits ABE:CD before finally the branch leading only to D and splitting it from ABCE. Tracing the path of A to D in any of the other three trees will take exactly the same route. Any other tip to tip journeys will likewise be the same in these four trees.

This is particularly important when comparing trees, particularly big ones. I have seen people invest a lot of time and effort (and sometimes manuscript space) speculating about the differences between two particular trees when, in fact, they were really the same tree and there was no difference. Alternatively, the topology might be the same but the differences might just be due to where the tree was rooted, which I will return to.

Branch Lengths

Once the topology is clear, the next things to look at are the branch lengths, as these can give key insights into how the tree can be interpreted and, sometimes, even the methods behind the tree. There are two key things to look at in this respect: (1) the distance between (not necessarily connected) internal nodes, shown with the red arrows below, and (2) the root-to-tip distances for each terminal node, shown by the coloured arrows in the figure below:
If the spacing is even (i.e. all the red arrows are the same length) then it is highly likely that branch lengths are not being shown and the tree is only displaying the toplogy. This can be confirmed by (a) the lack of a scale bar, and (b) a bias towards internal nodes towards the tips. (In the left tree, the node joining AB is aligned with that joining CD, not the deeper CDE ancestor.) If the spacing is not even then branch lengths are being shown. These should really be accompanied by a scale bar (although the figure about does not have any).

If branch lengths are being shown, the next thing to look at is the total root-to-tip distance for each terminal node. (The coloured arrows in the figure above.) If these are all the same length, as in the right-hand tree, it is highly likely that a molecular clock has been assumed (if it's a molecular phylogeny). If it hasn't been assumed - and the methods should provide enough details to know - then the molecule in question is just evolving in an incredibly clock-like fashion. More usually, these root-to-tip distances will not all be the same. If the tree is topology-only, as in the left-hand tree, the equal root-to-tip distances do not mean anything and no conclusions about rates can be reached.

Rooting

Evolutionary trees are (almost) always starting with an ancestor and then dividing, so you can always identify the root (if there is one) as the point where all the branches converge. Historically, it was drawn at the bottom like a real tree (as with the great Molluscan tree in OUMNH and the OneZoom Tree of Life Explorer). These days, it is usually drawn on the left as in these diagrams but I have seen trees with the root at the top, bottom or even on the right. (The latter is usually only used when mirroring another tree.) I have posted before on how to root a phylogenetic tree, so I won't go over that again here. The rooting method should be given in the methods but, when it is missing, you can often guess from the shape of the tree and using the root-to-tip branch lengths again:
Unrooted trees are pretty obvious when shown in the "radiation" style. If the tree is rooted, it is almost certainly either midpoint rooted or outgroup rooted (see "how to root a phylogenetic tree"). Midpoint rooting can be identified by virtue of the fact that the two longest root-to-tip distances will (a) be the same length and (b) be either side of the root. If either of these conditions is broken, it is not midpoint rooted and is probably outgroup rooted. (Note that if both conditions are met, it is still possible that the tree is outgroup rooted. Indeed, if the evolutionary rates are fairly consistent, outgroup rooting and midpoint rooting should be the same.)

Ideally, a rooted tree should have the root marked. Sometimes, however, it is left off, as in the bottom left. This can be confusing as tree visualising programs will often display trees in the "traditional" style even when they are not rooted. This is particularly a problem when branch lengths are not shown as it will not be at all obvious when the tree is rooted or not. The time that I see this catch people out most is when making a Maximum Parsimony tree using the popular software, MEGA - these trees are displayed randomly rooted and without branch lengths by default.

Reliability and Confidence Metrics

It is always important to consider how reliable the rooting method used is likely to be if conclusions are being reached regarding the direction of particular evolutionary events. Despite this, it's pretty rare for the root position to have a direct confidence measure associated with it (although I am sure there are ways to do it). What is common, however, is to have confidence metrics for the internal branches, which are usually placed above (or sometimes below) the branch next to the descendant node (in red, below). (Branch lengths, when shown, are normally below and nearer the middle of the branch.)
Bayesian and Maximum Likelihood methods quite often produce branch probabilities as part of the method but otherwise the most common method is "bootstrapping", which is a random sampling method. I will save bootstrapping and branch tests for future posts. My one tip for now: always remember that bootstrap values are associated with branches and not nodes.

Phylogenetic checklist

In summary, my checklist for reading a phylogenetic tree: topology ⇒ branch lengths? ⇒ molecular clock? ⇒ rooting ⇒ branch confidence metrics.

Saturday, 30 March 2013

SMBE has a shiny new website

I'll always have a bit of a soft spot for the journal "Molecular Biology and Evolution" (MBE). Not only does it combine two of my favourite things - molecular biology and evolution - but it was also where I published the main paper from my PhD, Transiently beneficial insertions could maintain mobile DNA sequences in variable environments. Although published by Oxford Journals, MBE is a journal of the Society for Molecular Biology & Evolution (SMBE), which also organises a large annual conference of the same name.

SMBE has a nice shiny new website at http://www.smbe.org/. As well as news on this and blog posts on relevant topics, you can also see the most read papers from MBE and SMBE's other journal, Genome Biology and Evolution (GBE). You can also keep up to date with SMBE via their new Twitter Stream and Facebook page. (The current Secretary and Treasurer of SMBE are both members of VIBE, the Virtual Institute of Bioinformatics & Evolution (formerly the "Virtual Institute of Bioinformatics, Eire"), through which I got my first postdoc, so it must be good! I miss VIBE meetings!)